The fallout between Hatebreed and former bassist Chris Beattie just took another turn, with a Connecticut judge ruling the case will move forward after the band’s attempt to shut it down was denied.
It’s a significant development in what’s become one of hardcore’s messiest internal splits in recent memory (per Lamb Goat).
Court rejects Hatebreed’s attempt to strike claims
Last week, the Superior Court in New Haven rejected efforts from Hatebreed and frontman Jamey Jasta to dismiss key parts of Beattie’s lawsuit.
The band had moved to strike multiple claims, including breach of contract, emotional distress, unjust enrichment and interference tied to their long running business relationship.
The court knocked all of that back, that means Beattie’s case remains intact, and the legal fight is heading deeper rather than fading out early.
How things unravelled
Beattie, a founding member who spent roughly three decades in the band, was officially replaced in early 2025, at the time there was no explanation.
Two days later, he broke the silence, stating his firing in November 2024 was “uncalled for and based on misleading and wrongful statements that will be subject to future actions.”
Those “future actions” turned into a lawsuit that’s now gaining traction.
As previously reported, Beattie alleges he was pushed out following internal tensions, including disputes over finances and decision-making within the band’s operations, he claims there was a long standing understanding of equal partnership that began to erode in the lead up to his exit.
What happens next
The next step is a Judicial ADR Event scheduled for early June, essentially a court led settlement meeting where both sides will attempt to resolve the dispute without heading to trial.
If that doesn’t happen, the case is set to move toward a full trial, with jury selection pencilled in for April 2027.
Where it lands
For a band like Hatebreed, known for consistency and loyalty in a scene that doesn’t forget, this situation cuts deeper than a standard lineup change.
There’s still a long road ahead legally, but one thing’s clear. This isn’t being quietly settled behind the scenes, not yet anyway.
Follow me for more on the Australian and US Metal Scene:
MORE IN Music
